Biomag 2016 satellite meeting
From raw MEG to publication:
How to perform MEG group analysis with free academic software.
General information
| When | October 2nd, 8:30-1pm | |
| Speakers | Alexandre Gramfort | MNE, Telecom ParisTech |
| Vladimir Litvak Rebecca Beresford | SPM, UCL, UK | |
| Leighton Hinkley | NUTMEG, UCSF, USA | |
| Robert Oostenveld | FieldTrip, Donders Inst., The Netherlands | |
| Francois Tadel | Brainstorm, McGill Univ., Canada | |
| Registration | 40$ | 71 registered participants | |
Online resources
| Introduction | Presentation of the dataset |
| Brainstorm | Single subject tutorial Slides: powerpoint | pdf |
| FieldTrip | http://www.fieldtriptoolbox.org/workshop/biomag2016 |
| MNE | http://mne-tools.github.io/mne-biomag-group-demo/ |
| NUTMEG | http://www.nitrc.org/plugins/mwiki/index.php/nutmeg:MainPage |
| SPM | SPM12 Manual, chapter 42 Slides: Rebecca Beresford | Vladimir Litvak |
Abstract
Free academic toolboxes have gained increasing prominence in MEG analysis as a means to disseminate cutting edge methods, share best practices between different research groups and pool resources for developing essential tools for the MEG community. In the recent years large and vibrant research communities have emerged around several of these toolboxes. Teaching events are regularly held around the world where the basics of each toolbox are explained by its respective developers and experienced power users. There are, however, two knowledge gaps that our BIOMAG satellite symposium aims to address. Firstly, most teaching examples only show analysis of a single ‘typical best’ subject whereas most real MEG studies involve analysis of group data. It is then left to the researchers in the field to figure out for themselves how to make the transition and obtain significant group results. Secondly, we are not familiar with any examples of fully analyzing the same group dataset with different academic toolboxes to assess the degree of agreement in scientific conclusions and compare strengths and weaknesses of various analysis methods and their independent implementations. Our workshop is organised by the lead developers of six most popular free academic MEG toolboxes (in alphabetic order): Brainstorm, EEGLAB, FieldTrip, MNE, NUTMEG, and SPM. Ahead of the workshop the research team for each toolbox will analyze the same group MEG/EEG dataset. This dataset containing evoked responses to face stimuli was acquired by Richard Henson and Daniel Wakeman, who won a special award at BIOMAG2010 to make it freely available to the community. All the raw data are available at https://openfmri.org/dataset/ds000117/.
Detailed instructions for each toolbox will be made available online including analysis scripts and figures of results. All analyses will show a full pipeline from the raw data to detailed publication quality results. Researchers who are interested in using the respective toolbox will then be able to reproduce the analysis in their lab and port it to their own data.
At the workshop each group will briefly introduce their software and present the key results from their analysis. This will be followed by a panel discussion and questions from the audience.
Following the event we plan to integrate the suggestions and questions from the workshop audience and to publish the analyses details as part of a special research topic in Frontiers in Neuroscience, section Brain Imaging Methods so that the proposed best practices will be endorsed by peer review and become citable in future publications. Other research groups will be invited to contribute to the research topic as long as they present detailed descriptions of analyses of group data that are freely available online and make it possible for others to fully reproduce their analysis and results.
We hope that this proposal will lead to creation of invaluable resource for the whole MEG community and the workshop will contribute to establishment of good practice and promoting consistent and reproducible analyses approaches. The event will also showcase all the toolboxes and will be of interest to beginners in the field with basic background in MEG who contemplate the most suitable analysis approach and software for their study as well as to experienced researchers who would like to get up to date with the latest methodological developments.
Program
Each group will present their software and develop more specifically one topic common to all the programs.
| 8:30-9:00 | Welcome and registration |
| 9:00-9:15 | Introduction to the dataset |
| 9:15-9:45 | FieldTrip, Robert Oostenveld Highlight: Reading and converting files with the fileio library |
| 9:45-10:15 | MNE, Alexandre Gramfort Highlight: Pre-processing and filtering |
| 10:15-10:45 | Brainstorm, Francois Tadel Highlight: Data reviewing, event marking and epoching |
| 10:45-11:00 | Coffee break |
| 11:00-11:30 | NUTMEG, Leighton Hinkley Highlight: Time-frequency analysis |
| 11:30-12:00 | SPM, Rebecca Beresford & Vladimir Litvak Highlight: Averaging/Combine planar |
| 12:10-13:00 | Panel discussion Moderator: Jason Taylor, Univ Manchester, UK |