|
Size: 5796
Comment:
|
Size: 8122
Comment:
|
| Deletions are marked like this. | Additions are marked like this. |
| Line 9: | Line 9: |
| Reviewers ''[current reviewing status] '' | Reviewers: ''[current reviewing status] '' |
| Line 11: | Line 11: |
| * '''Sylvain Baillet''': Montreal Neurological Institute ''[overview 1-14, no proofreading]'' * '''Richard Leahy''': University of Southern California ''[validated 1-19]'' * '''John Mosher''': Cleveland Clinic ''[not started]'' |
* '''Sylvain Baillet''': Montreal Neurological Institute ''[overview 1-14, edited 20-21]'' * '''Richard Leahy''': University of Southern California ''[validated 1-20]'' * '''John Mosher''': Cleveland Clinic ''[edited 22 only]'' |
| Line 15: | Line 15: |
Expected timeline (2016) * '''March''': Tutorials #1-#21 (interface and pre-processing) * '''April''': Tutorials #22-#24 (source estimation and time-frequency) * '''May-June''': Tutorials #25-#28 (statistics and workflows) * '''July-Sept''': Cross-validation of the pipeline and the results with MNE, FieldTrip and SPM * '''October''': Presentation during a satellite meeting at the Biomag 2016 conference * '''Nov-Dec''': Connectivity tutorial |
|
| Line 27: | Line 18: |
| == Tutorial 10: Power spectrum and frequency filters == | == Inverse models == === Tutorial 22: Source estimation === |
| Line 30: | Line 22: |
| * Richard, John, Sylvain: Finish the evaluation of the band-pass filters used in Brainstorm * Richard, John, Sylvain: Why is the notch filter not working well at the beginning of the signal? * Francois: Mark with an extended event the time segments that we cannot trust (edge effect) * Francois: Add warning if recordings are not long enough * Francois: Check that the bandpass filter is always used with enough data (Hilbert transform, SSP) [ONLINE DOC] * Richard, John, Sylvain: Section [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/ArtifactsFilter#What_filters_to_apply.3F_.5BTODO.5D|What filters to apply?]] * Richard, John, Sylvain: Section [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/ArtifactsFilter#Filters_specifications_.5BTODO.5D|Filters specifications]] == Tutorial 12: Artifact detection == [ONLINE DOC] * Beth: Adding examples of the different detection processes. Section [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/ArtifactsDetect#Other_detection_processes|Other detection processes]] == Tutorial 13: Artifact cleaning with SSP == [CODE] [ONLINE DOC] * Francois: Check the length needed to filter the recordings (after finishing #10) <<BR>>Section [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/ArtifactsSsp#SSP_Algorithm_.5BTODO.5D|SSP Algorithm]] == Tutorial 15: Import epochs == [ONLINE DOC] * Richard, Sylvain, John, Francois: Define recommendations for epoch lengths (after finishing #10) <<BR>>Section [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/Epoching#Epoch_length_.5BTODO.5D|Epoch length]] == Tutorial 20: Head modelling == [ONLINE DOC] * John, Richard, Sylvain: In-depth review of this sensitive tutorial * John, Richard, Sylvain: Section [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/AllIntroduction#Tutorials.2FHeadModel.References_.5BTODO.5D|References]] == Tutorial 22: Source estimation == [CODE] * John: Dipole scanning: Wrong orientations * John: Inverse code: sLORETA * John: Inverse code: NAI * John: Inverse code: Mixed head models * John, Richard, Sylvain: How to normalize unconstrained sources ? * Francois: Remove the warning messages in the interface |
* '''John''': Inverse code: Mixed head models are still not supported. * '''John''': Explain the new (incorrect) results obtained with the epilepsy tutorial (see below) * '''John''': Drop the option "RMS source amplitude"? * The documentation is not informative and not encouraging at all: "RMS source amplitude: An alternative definition of SNR, but still under test and may be dropped." * The option is not even accessible in the interface: you successively asked me to disable it for the min norm, and then made me hide the entire section "Regularization parameter" for the dipole modelling and the beamformer. * Can I just remove it from the interface? * Francois: Update code, tutorials and screen captures accordingly * '''John, Richard, Sylvain, Matti, Alex''': Make the "median eigenvalue" option the default? * John suggests to use the "median eigenvalue" option by default instead of the option "Regularize noise covariance", which as been used for many years. * In [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/SourceEstimation#Advanced_options:_Minimum_norm|this section]] of the tutorials, John wrote: "'''Recommended option''': This author (Mosher) votes for the '''median eigenvalue '''as being generally effective. The other options are useful for comparing with other software packages that generally employ similar regularization methods." * However this modifies a lot the results: the localization results and the MN amplitudes can be very different. If this is a clear improvement, it's good to promote it. But it cannot be done randomly like this, this has to be discussed (especially with Matti and Alex) and tested. * John: Please arrange a meeting so you can discuss this question. * '''John, Richard, Sylvain''': Why are dSPM values 2x lower than Z-score ? * The tutorial says "Z-normalized current density maps are also easy to interpret. They represent explicitly a "deviation from experimental baseline" as defined by the user. In contrast, dSPM indicates the deviation from the data that was used to define the noise covariance used in computing the min norm map. " * Therefore should we expect the dSPM values to deviate more from the noise recordings, than the Z-score from the pre-stim baseline? Instead of this we observe much lower values. Is there a scaling issue here? <<BR>><<BR>> {{attachment:diff_zscore_dspm.gif||width="385",height="138"}} * Mixing GRAD and MAG: * '''John''': You do not recommend processing GRAD and MAG at the same time? This is currently the default behavior in the interface... * '''John''': Please discuss this with Matti and Alex * Francois: Change the default + add note in Elekta tutorial if change is validated * '''John''': Send a message to Margot Taylor: She's been asking for your beamformers for about 2yrs. |
| Line 75: | Line 46: |
| * John, Richard, Sylvain: Section [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/SourceEstimation#Source_estimation_options_.5BTODO.5D|Source estimation options]] * John, Richard, Sylvain: Section [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/SourceEstimation#Advanced_options_.5BTODO.5D|Advanced options]] * John, Richard, Sylvain: Section [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/SourceEstimation#Equations_.5BTODO.5D|Equations]] * John, Richard, Sylvain: Section [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/SourceEstimation#References_.5BTODO.5D|References]] * John, Richard, Sylvain: Why are dSPM values 2x lower than Z-score ? * John, Richard, Sylvain: In-depth review of this sensitive tutorial |
* '''John''': Fix all the missing links * '''John, Richard, Sylvain''': Section [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/SourceEstimation#References_.5BTODO.5D|References]] * '''John, Richard, Sylvain''': What do with [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/Beamformers|Hui-Ling Beamformers]]? * '''John''': Data covariance: * Recommendations moved to the [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/NoiseCovariance#Data_covariance_.5BTODO.5D|Noise and data covariance tutorial]]. * You said: "Our recommendation for evoked responses is to use a window that spans prestim through the end of the response of interest, with a minimum of 500ms total duration. " * Should I modify the interface (and screen capture of the example) to always include the pre-stim baseline (eg. from -100ms to +500ms, instead of from 0ms to +500ms) ? * '''Francois''': Update the screen capture + code for default selection of the time window === Tutorial: Dipole scanning === * '''John''': Add the description of all the measures in [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/TutDipScan#Significance_mesures_.5BTODO.5D|this section]]. === Tutorial EEG/Epilepsy === * '''John''': Why sLORETA? * '''John''': Please address the location issues with the new code: <<BR>>dSPM is now localizing the spike in a much deeper spot (top=old version, bottom=new version) <<BR>><<BR>> {{attachment:epilepsy_dspm.gif||width="272",height="233"}} * '''Marcel Heers''' wrote: "Looking at the findings from the intracranial EEG in Matthias Dümpelmann's article (figure 1 panel a) and b)) it is '''very likely the new sources are wrong'''. Additionally, the older sources are much more in agreement with Matthias' sLORETA results and with cMEM findings. Sohrabopour et al. reported as well that their IRES method found results in agreement with sources shown in the tutorial." * Imported data for testing can be downloaded here:<<BR>> https://www.dropbox.com/s/42d9indpjr8ac1y/TutorialEpilepsy.zip?dl=0 == Filters == === Tutorial 10: Power spectrum and frequency filters === [CODE] * '''Richard, Hossein''': Define reasonable transient durations * '''Richard, Hossein''': Update the code for the band-stop and notch filters in the same way * '''Richard, Hossein''': Frequency resolution in the "freqz" plots for high-pass filters under 0.5Hz * '''Richard, John, Hossein, Sylvain''': Address the issue of the weird PSD plots for Elekta recordings [ONLINE DOC] * '''Richard, Hossein''': Section [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/ArtifactsFilter#Filters_specifications_.5BTODO.5D|Filters specifications]] for band-stop and notch filters === Tutorial 13: Artifact cleaning with SSP === * Francois: Check the length needed to filter the recordings (after finishing #10) <<BR>>Section [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/ArtifactsSsp#SSP_Algorithm_.5BTODO.5D|SSP Algorithm]] === Tutorial 15: Import epochs === * Richard, Sylvain, John, Francois: Define recommendations for epoch lengths (after finishing #10) <<BR>>Section [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/Epoching#Epoch_length_.5BTODO.5D|Epoch length]] === Tutorial 22: Source estimation === * Francois: Update screen capture in section [[http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/SourceEstimation#Averaging_in_source_space|Averaging in source space]] |
| Line 85: | Line 89: |
| * Enable option "Hide edge effects" for Hilbert (after finishing #10) | * Francois: Enable option "Hide edge effects" for Hilbert (after finishing #10) |
| Line 89: | Line 93: |
| * Hilbert: Link back to the filters tutorial (after finishing #10) * ERS/ERD on Hilbert: Squared signal only? * Shouldn't we always use power?... Right now, even the averaging process for trials give inconsistent results across methods. * Describe what happens with unconstrained sources == Tutorial 26: Statistics == [CODE] [ONLINE DOC] |
* Francois: Hilbert: Link back to the filters tutorial (after finishing #10) |
| Line 100: | Line 96: |
| * Everything == Tutorial 28: Scripting == * Everything |
* Add Chi2(log) ? |
| Line 106: | Line 99: |
| * Francois: Check that the script tutorial_introduction.m produces the same output as tutorials | * Francois: Remove all the wiki pages that are not used |
| Line 108: | Line 101: |
| * Francois: Check the number of pages for each tutorial | * Francois: Remove useless images from all tutorials |
| Line 110: | Line 103: |
<<BR>><<BR>><<BR>><<BR>><<BR>>[Additional important stuff] == Phantom tutorial (for validation) == * John: Prepare Elekta recordings to distribute on the [[Tutorials/PhantomElekta|tutorial page]] * Francois: Prepare the Elekta phantom anatomy * Francois: Prepare the analysis script * Francois: Edit the tutorial page == Other analysis scenarios == * Francois: Update all the tutorials (100 pages) * Francois: Add number of pages in the tutorials |
|
| Line 125: | Line 106: |
| * Richard, Sylvain: Define example dataset and precise results to obtain from them * Richard: How to assess significance from connectivity matrices * Francois: Preparation of a tutorial |
* '''Richard, Sylvain''': Define example dataset and precise results to obtain from them * '''Richard, Sylvain''': How to deal with unconstrained sources?<<BR>> http://neuroimage.usc.edu/forums/showthread.php?2401 * '''Richard''': How to assess significance from connectivity matrices? * '''Richard, Hossein, Francois''': Preparation of a tutorial |
Introduction tutorials: Editing process
http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials
Redactors:
Francois Tadel: Montreal Neurological Institute
Elizabeth Bock: Montreal Neurological Institute
Reviewers: [current reviewing status]
Sylvain Baillet: Montreal Neurological Institute [overview 1-14, edited 20-21]
Richard Leahy: University of Southern California [validated 1-20]
John Mosher: Cleveland Clinic [edited 22 only]
Dimitrios Pantazis: Massachusetts Institute of Technology [validated 1-15]
Inverse models
Tutorial 22: Source estimation
[CODE]
John: Inverse code: Mixed head models are still not supported.
John: Explain the new (incorrect) results obtained with the epilepsy tutorial (see below)
John: Drop the option "RMS source amplitude"?
- The documentation is not informative and not encouraging at all: "RMS source amplitude: An alternative definition of SNR, but still under test and may be dropped."
- The option is not even accessible in the interface: you successively asked me to disable it for the min norm, and then made me hide the entire section "Regularization parameter" for the dipole modelling and the beamformer.
- Can I just remove it from the interface?
- Francois: Update code, tutorials and screen captures accordingly
John, Richard, Sylvain, Matti, Alex: Make the "median eigenvalue" option the default?
- John suggests to use the "median eigenvalue" option by default instead of the option "Regularize noise covariance", which as been used for many years.
In this section of the tutorials, John wrote: "Recommended option: This author (Mosher) votes for the median eigenvalue as being generally effective. The other options are useful for comparing with other software packages that generally employ similar regularization methods."
- However this modifies a lot the results: the localization results and the MN amplitudes can be very different. If this is a clear improvement, it's good to promote it. But it cannot be done randomly like this, this has to be discussed (especially with Matti and Alex) and tested.
- John: Please arrange a meeting so you can discuss this question.
John, Richard, Sylvain: Why are dSPM values 2x lower than Z-score ?
- The tutorial says "Z-normalized current density maps are also easy to interpret. They represent explicitly a "deviation from experimental baseline" as defined by the user. In contrast, dSPM indicates the deviation from the data that was used to define the noise covariance used in computing the min norm map. "
Therefore should we expect the dSPM values to deviate more from the noise recordings, than the Z-score from the pre-stim baseline? Instead of this we observe much lower values. Is there a scaling issue here?
- Mixing GRAD and MAG:
John: You do not recommend processing GRAD and MAG at the same time? This is currently the default behavior in the interface...
John: Please discuss this with Matti and Alex
- Francois: Change the default + add note in Elekta tutorial if change is validated
John: Send a message to Margot Taylor: She's been asking for your beamformers for about 2yrs.
Francois: Call FieldTrip headmodels and beamformers
[ONLINE DOC]
John: Fix all the missing links
John, Richard, Sylvain: Section References
John, Richard, Sylvain: What do with Hui-Ling Beamformers?
John: Data covariance:
Recommendations moved to the Noise and data covariance tutorial.
- You said: "Our recommendation for evoked responses is to use a window that spans prestim through the end of the response of interest, with a minimum of 500ms total duration. "
- Should I modify the interface (and screen capture of the example) to always include the pre-stim baseline (eg. from -100ms to +500ms, instead of from 0ms to +500ms) ?
Francois: Update the screen capture + code for default selection of the time window
Tutorial: Dipole scanning
John: Add the description of all the measures in this section.
Tutorial EEG/Epilepsy
John: Why sLORETA?
John: Please address the location issues with the new code:
dSPM is now localizing the spike in a much deeper spot (top=old version, bottom=new version)
Marcel Heers wrote: "Looking at the findings from the intracranial EEG in Matthias Dümpelmann's article (figure 1 panel a) and b)) it is very likely the new sources are wrong. Additionally, the older sources are much more in agreement with Matthias' sLORETA results and with cMEM findings. Sohrabopour et al. reported as well that their IRES method found results in agreement with sources shown in the tutorial."
Imported data for testing can be downloaded here:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/42d9indpjr8ac1y/TutorialEpilepsy.zip?dl=0
Filters
Tutorial 10: Power spectrum and frequency filters
[CODE]
Richard, Hossein: Define reasonable transient durations
Richard, Hossein: Update the code for the band-stop and notch filters in the same way
Richard, Hossein: Frequency resolution in the "freqz" plots for high-pass filters under 0.5Hz
Richard, John, Hossein, Sylvain: Address the issue of the weird PSD plots for Elekta recordings
[ONLINE DOC]
Richard, Hossein: Section Filters specifications for band-stop and notch filters
Tutorial 13: Artifact cleaning with SSP
Francois: Check the length needed to filter the recordings (after finishing #10)
Section SSP Algorithm
Tutorial 15: Import epochs
Richard, Sylvain, John, Francois: Define recommendations for epoch lengths (after finishing #10)
Section Epoch length
Tutorial 22: Source estimation
Francois: Update screen capture in section Averaging in source space
Tutorial 24: Time-frequency
[CODE]
- Francois: Enable option "Hide edge effects" for Hilbert (after finishing #10)
[ONLINE DOC]
- Francois: Hilbert: Link back to the filters tutorial (after finishing #10)
Tutorial 27: Workflows
- Add Chi2(log) ?
Final steps
- Francois: Remove all the wiki pages that are not used
- Francois: Check all the links in all the pages
- Francois: Remove useless images from all tutorials
Francois: Reference on ResearchGate, Academia and Google Scholar
http://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/AllIntroduction
Connectivity
- Not documented at all
Richard, Sylvain: Define example dataset and precise results to obtain from them
Richard, Sylvain: How to deal with unconstrained sources?
http://neuroimage.usc.edu/forums/showthread.php?2401Richard: How to assess significance from connectivity matrices?
Richard, Hossein, Francois: Preparation of a tutorial