Differences between revisions 13 and 80 (spanning 67 versions)

[TUTORIAL UNDER CONSTRUCTION: NOT READY FOR PUBLIC USE]

FEM tensors estimation with BrainSuite

Authors: Takfarinas Medani, Francois Tadel, Anand Joshi and Richard Leahy

In this tutorial, we describe the estimation of realistic conductivity tensors of living brain tissues using the BrainSuite software. These results are used in FEM forward modeling, as described in the tutorials: FEM with DUNEuro and FEM median nerve example.

The realistic tensors are estimated from the Diffusion-Weighted Images (DWI): Brainstorm calls the BrainSuite software to compute the diffusion tensors on each brain MRI voxel (DTI), then Effective Medium Approach (EMA) is applied to estimate the conductivity tensors for each element of a tetrahedral FEM mesh. This is particularly interesting for the modeling the anisotropy of the white matter.

BrainSuite is also used for other purposes in Brainstorm, particularly the T1 MRI segmentation, as documented in this tutorial: MRI segmentation: BrainSuite.

Contents

Download and installation
Import the anatomy
FEM mesh
Simulated conductivity tensor
Troubleshooting
References

Download and installation

Requirements

You have already followed all the introduction tutorials.
You have a working copy of Brainstorm installed on your computer.
For the DWI data, only the NIfTI files (.nii) are supported.

Install Brainsuite

Download the latest version of BrainSuite from http://forums.brainsuite.org/download/.
Install it on your computer by following the instructions in BrainSuite's quick start installation guide.
You will be using BrainSuite Diffusion Pipeline (BDP), so you need to install a compatible MATLAB Runtime (2019b for BrainSuite 21a).
In Brainstorm, menu File > Edit preferences > Enter the BrainSuite installation folder:

Download the dataset

Download the files: MRI T1w and MRI DWI (from the BrainSuite diffusion tutorial).
Unzip it outside of any of the Brainstorm folders (program folder or database folder).
Start Brainstorm (Matlab scripts or stand-alone version)
Select the menu File > Create new protocol. Name it "TutorialTensors" and select:
- No, use individual anatomy
- No, use one channel file per condition

Import the anatomy

T1 MRI

Switch to the "anatomical data" view, the left button in the toolbar above the database explorer.
Right-click on the TutorialFem folder > New subject > Subject01
- Keep the default options you set for the protocol.
Right-click on the subject node > Import MRI:
- Set the file format: All MRI files (subject space)
- Select the T1 file: BrainSuiteTutorialSVReg/2523412.nii.gz
Click on the link "Click here to compute MNI normalization": option "maff8". This estimates an affine transformation to the MNI space and sets default positions for the anatomical fiducials. The NAS/LPA/RPA fiducials are needed for defining the Brainstorm subject coordinate system, in which the surfaces and FEM meshes are stored.

Diffusion imaging

This computes the This requires BrainSuite to be installed on your computer, with the bdp program available in the system path.

Right-click on Subject01 > Convert DWI to DTI
Select the DWI file: DWI/2523412.dwi.nii.gz
The associated text files *.bvec (orientation of the gradient) and *.bval (value of the gradient) must be in the same folder, with the same file name. Theses files are created from for the DWI acquisition. If you don't have them, ask the person who programmed your DWI sequence and get the files that are specific to your use case.
The process can take up to 30min. At the end, a new file DTI-EIG appears in the database (DTI=diffusion tensors images, EIG=eigenvalue). This file contains 12 volumes, ie. 12 values for each voxel. From 1 to 9: components of the three eigenvectors; from 10 to 12: the values of their norm to the eigenvalue.

FEM mesh

The FEM approach requires a segmentation of the head volume in different tissues, represented as hexahedral or tetrahedral 3D meshes. The methods available within Brainstorm are listed in the tutorial FEM mesh generation.

Here we illustrate only the use of Brain2mesh: this is not the most accurate solution for MRI segmentation but it is probably the fastest solution to obtain a tetrahedral mesh of the head with 5 tissues (gray matter, white matter, CSF, skull, skin). For more accurate results, we recommend using SimNIBS with T1+T2, as illustrated in the tutorial FEM median nerve example.

Right-click on the T1 MRI > MRI segmentation > Generate FEM mesh > Brain2mesh.
After less than 15 minutes, you will obtain a new FEM mesh in the database.

Conductivity tensor generation from DTI

The Effective Medium Approach is applied to convert the diffusion tensors to the conductivity tensors.

www.pnas.org/content/98/20/11697

Computation of FEM mesh tensors

Once the FEM mesh and the DTI tensors are available in the Brainstorm database, the next step for the FEM tensors can be performed by the following:

- Right-click on the FEM mesh - Compute FEM tensors

Brainstorm checks the available tissues in the FEM head model and displays the following panel

This panel lists the tissues available in the FEM head model and assigns a default value of the conductivity for each compartment. Users can change these values to their own if needed.

DTI values can be used to generate conductivity tensors for the white matter (and in some cases for the grey matter). Please, note that the DWI can be used only for the brain tissues and not for the outers compartments (skull and skin)

In this tutorial (and in most cases) we select the white matter. Select the WM anisotropy and keep all the other tissues as isotropic, then these additional options appear asking for the method to use.

The available methods are:

- Effective Medium approach (EMA)

- Effective Medium approach with volume constraints (EMA + VC)

- Simulated or the artificial anisotropy

Only the two first methods require the DTI. More information about these methods can be found on these references [ref1][ref2] and in our main paper [link]

In this tutorial, we use the method "EMA + VC", where the final tensors are constrained to fits the volume of the equivalent isotropic tensor volume.

Visulation of FEM mesh tensors

Once the FEM tensors are successfully computed, they are stored in the FEM head node. By right-clicking on the FEM head, new menu items are added that gives the possibilities to display the FEM tensors either as ellipsoids or as vectors in the direction of the main eigenvector.

The tensors can be displayed either on the FEM mesh or overlaid on the MRI. The following figures show an example of the obtained tensors displayed on the white matter.

On the left, the tensors as a line on the direction of the main eigenvector. On the right, the tensors displayed as ellipsoids. The orientation of the tensor is color-coded as follows: red for right-left, green for anterior-posterior, and blue for superior-inferior.

Note that the quality of the tensors depends on the DWI data and the number of acquisition direction.

Users can also display the tensors on specific tissues, for example on the white matter (left figure) or overlay on the MRI (right figure).

Recommendation

In the case where the user wants to use generate isotropic tensors, then the DTI is not required. For that case, keep all the options to 'isotropic', the recommended display is the 'Ellipsoids', and the final shape will be a sphere (isotropic direction). In the case where more than one FEM head model is in the database, the highlighted one in the green color will be used.

Advanced

Simulated conductivity tensor

In the case where the DWI is not available, or in the case where the users desire to evaluate the effect of the conductivity change on the head model, the artificial conductivity can be used.

Users can reach this option by following this tutorial and select the third method in this panel.

Two approaches are integrated within Brainstorm. Either Wang's constraint or the volume's constraint (Wolters). The common feature between these methods is the ratio between the transversal and longitudinal conductivity ratio.

A common example is the skull anisotropy simulation, where the longitudinal conductivity can be higher than the transversal conductivity, the ratio can vary from 2 to 10 [ref]. In this tutorial, we keep all the tissue as isotropic, except the skull, we use a ratio of 0.1 and select the volume constraint. The following figures show the results of this example.

"eigenvalues parallel (longitudinal) and perpendicular (transverse) to the fiber directions" for 1:10 anisotropy (transverse:longitudinal)

Troubleshooting

To be completed soon and linked to BrainSuite website

References

===TODO===

Check the error in the simnibs mesh in X direction and overlay on mri check the error with the brain2mesh Correct the ratio from integer to float check the meaning of transversal/longitidunal in the code add an interactive way yo change the size of the tensor.. important correct the name of the simulated method, correct the EMC and remove the VC and change the coefficcient

-  ⇤ ← Revision 13 as of 2020-08-21 18:57:15 → 
  Size: 4242
  Editor: TakfarinasMedani
  Comment: better description than the previous name
+   ← Revision 80 as of 2021-08-17 14:56:06 → ⇥
  Size: 11271
  Editor: FrancoisTadel
  Comment:
-Deletions are marked like this.
+Additions are marked like this.
 Line 1:
-## page was renamed from brainsuiteBDP
## page was renamed from brainsuite
+'''[TUTORIAL UNDER CONSTRUCTION: NOT READY FOR PUBLIC USE]'''

----
-Line 6:
+Line 8:
-'''[TUTORIAL UNDER WRITING: NOT READY FOR PUBLIC USE]'''
+In this tutorial, we describe the estimation of realistic conductivity tensors of living brain tissues using the [[http://brainsuite.org/|BrainSuite software]].   These results are used in FEM forward modeling, as described in the tutorials: [[https://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/Duneuro#DUNEuro_options:_Advanced|FEM with DUNEuro]] and [[https://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/FemMedianNerve#FEM_tensors|FEM median nerve example]].
-Line 8:
+Line 10:
-Describe brainsuite here : here we will describe the process of the brain tissues anisotrpy estimation and the different functions that brainstorm offers.
+The realistic tensors are estimated from the Diffusion-Weighted Images (DWI): Brainstorm calls the BrainSuite software to compute the diffusion tensors on each brain MRI voxel (DTI), then Effective Medium Approach (EMA) is applied to estimate the conductivity tensors for each element of a tetrahedral FEM mesh. This is particularly interesting for the modeling the anisotropy of the white  matter.
-Line 10:
+Line 12:
-This tutorial explains how to use Brainsuite to estimate the anisotropy of the brain tissues.

refer to this page

[[https://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/SegBrainSuite?highlight=(anand)|https://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/SegBrainSuite?highlight=%28anand%29]]
+BrainSuite is also used for other purposes in Brainstorm, particularly the T1 MRI segmentation, as  documented in this tutorial: [[Tutorials/SegBrainSuite|MRI segmentation: BrainSuite]].
-Line 18:
+Line 16:
-== Installation ==
 1. Download the latest version of BrainSuite from http://www.brainsuite.org/download.
+== Download and installation ==
==== Requirements ====
 * You have  already  followed all the  introduction tutorials.
 * You have a working copy of   Brainstorm  installed on your computer.
 * For the DWI data, only the NIfTI files (.nii) are supported.

==== Install Brainsuite ====
 1. Download the latest version of BrainSuite from http://forums.brainsuite.org/download/.
-Line 21:
+Line 26:
-. Note that you will be using BrainSuite Diffusion Pipeline(BDP), so you need to install a compatible [[http://www.mathworks.com/products/compiler/mcr|MATLAB Compiler Runtime]](last version).
 1. Start BrainSuite to check if the installation (It's not required to open BrainSuite to run this tutorial).
-Line 24:
+Line 27:
-== Requirement ==
 * You have already followed all the introduction tutorials
 * You have already generated the FEM mesh as explained here (link to the FEM mesh tutorial)
 * You have a working copy of Brainstorm installed on your computer
 * Get the open access reference data set from''' '''here'''  link todataset of Ernie / simnibs'''
+. You will be using BrainSuite Diffusion Pipeline (BDP), so you need to install a compatible [[https://www.mathworks.com/products/compiler/matlab-runtime.html|MATLAB Runtime]] (2019b for BrainSuite 21a).
-Line 30:
+Line 29:
-The BrainSuite installation folder should be informed in the Brainstorm preferences:
+. In Brainstorm, menu File > Edit preferences > Enter the BrainSuite installation folder:<<BR>><<BR>> {{attachment:brainsuiteInstall.gif}}
-Line 32:
+Line 31:
-{{https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/6920058/81406567-1c785400-913a-11ea-9048-28c7459af7da.png|image}}
+==== Download the dataset ====
 * Download the files: [[http://brainsuite.org/WebTutorialData/BrainSuiteTutorialSVReg_Sept16.zip|MRI T1w]] and [[http://brainsuite.org/WebTutorialData/DWI_Feb15.zip|MRI DWI]] (from the [[http://brainsuite.org/tutorials/dtiexercise/|BrainSuite diffusion tutorial]]).
 Line 34:
-== Import data ==
Onc you have imported the MRI and generated a FEM mesh. You can call the process to generate the FEM tensors. In the folowing, both the realistic tensors from the DWI and the artificial tensors will be generated.
+ * Unzip it outside of any of the Brainstorm folders (program   folder or database folder).
 * Start Brainstorm (Matlab scripts or stand-alone version)
 * Select the menu File > Create new protocol. Name it "'''TutorialTensors'''" and select:
  * No, use individual anatomy
  * No, use one channel file per condition
-Line 37:
+Line 40:
-== Realistic condctivity tensors ==
The realistic tensors are estimated from the Diffusion Weighted Images (DWI). For this purpose, Brainstorm calls internally the BrainSuite Diffusion Pipline to compute the diffusion tensors on each brain voxel. Afterwards, the Effective Medium Appeach is applied to convert the diffusion tensors to the conductivity tensors. The following section shows to the users how to do it from the graphical intefrace.
+== Import the anatomy ==
=== T1 MRI ===
 * Switch to the "anatomical data" view, the left button in the toolbar above the database explorer.
 * Right-click on the TutorialFem folder > New subject > '''Subject01'''
  * Keep the default options you set for the protocol.
-Line 40:
+Line 46:
-Only the NIfTI are supported. All the diffusion data, inclusing the DWI file and direction and the value of the gradient files , respectively the the *.nii, the *.bval and  the *.bvec are required. Ideally these files should have the same name and saved in the same folder.
+ * Right-click on the subject node > '''Import MRI''':
  * Set the file format: '''All MRI files (subject space)'''
-Line 42:
+Line 49:
-The FEM head model to use for tensors should be selected and highlighted with the green color (double click on the FEM mesh node to select it)
+  * Select the T1 file: BrainSuiteTutorialSVReg/'''2523412.nii.gz'''
-Line 44:
+Line 51:
-When this is done, then right-click on the subject > Convert DWI to DTI,
+ * Click on the link "'''Click here to compute MNI normalization'''": option "'''maff8'''". This estimates an affine transformation to the [[https://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/CoordinateSystems#MNI_coordinates|MNI space]] and sets default positions for the anatomical fiducials. The NAS/LPA/RPA fiducials are needed for defining the Brainstorm [[CoordinateSystems|subject coordinate system]], in which the surfaces and FEM meshes are stored. <<BR>><<BR>> {{attachment:importT1.gif}}
-Line 46:
+Line 53:
-Then follow the popup windows by selecting DWI, bval and bval. If these files are in the same folder, Brainstorm will detect them automatiquely, otherwise user will be asked to browse the files one by one.
+=== Diffusion imaging ===
This computes the  This requires BrainSuite to be installed on your computer, with the bdp program available in the system path.

 * Right-click on Subject01''' '''> '''Convert DWI to DTI'''

 * Select the DWI file: DWI/'''2523412.dwi.nii.gz'''

 * The associated text files '''*.bvec''' (orientation of the gradient) and '''*.bval''' (value of the gradient) must be in the same folder, with the same file name. Theses files are created from for the DWI acquisition. If you don't have  them, ask the person who programmed your DWI sequence and get the files  that are specific to your use case.

 * The process can take up to 30min. At the end, a new file '''DTI-EIG'''  appears in the database (DTI=diffusion tensors images, EIG=eigenvalue). This file contains 12 volumes, ie. 12 values  for each voxel. From 1 to 9: components of the three eigenvectors; from  10 to 12:  the values of their norm to the eigenvalue.  <<BR>><<BR>> {{attachment:importDTI.gif}}

== FEM mesh ==
The FEM approach requires a segmentation of the head volume in different  tissues, represented as hexahedral or tetrahedral 3D meshes. The  methods available within Brainstorm are listed in the tutorial [[https://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/FemMesh|FEM mesh generation]].

Here we illustrate only the use of '''Brain2mesh''': this is not the most accurate solution for MRI segmentation but it is probably the fastest solution to obtain a tetrahedral mesh of the head with 5 tissues (gray matter, white matter, CSF, skull, skin). For more accurate results, we recommend using '''SimNIBS with T1+T2''', as illustrated in the tutorial [[https://neuroimage.usc.edu/brainstorm/Tutorials/FemMedianNerve#FEM_mesh_with_SimNIBS|FEM median nerve example]].

 * Right-click on the T1 MRI > MRI segmentation > '''Generate FEM mesh''' > '''Brain2mesh'''.<<BR>><<BR>> {{attachment:femMesh.gif}}
 * After less than 15 minutes, you will obtain a new FEM mesh in the database.<<BR>><<BR>>{{attachment:femMesh2.gif}}

=== Conductivity tensor generation from DTI ===
The Effective Medium Approach is applied to convert the diffusion tensors to the conductivity tensors.

www.pnas.org/content/98/20/11697
-Line 50:
+Line 79:
-Brainstorm will load the avialbale tissue in the FEM head model and the following windows appears.
+==== Computation of FEM mesh tensors ====
Once the FEM mesh and the DTI tensors are available in the Brainstorm database, the next step for the FEM tensors can be performed by the following:
-Line 52:
+Line 82:
-Select the WM anisotropy and kee all the oher tissues as isotropic.
+- Right-click on the FEM mesh - Compute FEM tensors
-Line 54:
+Line 84:
-The process of conversion from DWI to Conductivity tensors use the EMA, furthermore, brainstorm propose the option to use the adaptative EMA with the volume constraint option [ref]. In this example we select the EMA with the VC.
+{{attachment:menuGenerateFemTensors.png||width="250",height="280"}}
-Line 56:
+Line 86:
-The process will take around 10 min, and then the FEM tensors are computed and stored in the FEM strucutre. [explain how it is organised and how to use it outside brainstorm ]
+Brainstorm checks the available tissues in the FEM head model and displays the following panel
-Line 58:
+Line 88:
-=== Display the tensors ===
== Artificial/simulated conductivity tensors ==
In the case where the DWI is not available, or the users desire to evaluates the effect of the conductivity change on the model, the artificial conductivity can be use.
+{{attachment:FEMConductivitiesIsoPanel.JPG||width="250",height="220"}}
-Line 62:
+Line 90:
-Two approaches are integrated within Brainstorm. Either the
+This panel lists the tissues available in the FEM head model and assigns a default value of the conductivity for each compartment. Users can change these values to their own if needed.

DTI values can be used to generate conductivity tensors for the white matter (and in some cases for the grey matter). Please, note that the DWI can be used only for the brain tissues and not for the outers compartments (skull and skin)

In this tutorial (and in most cases) we select the white matter. Select the WM anisotropy and keep all the other tissues as isotropic, then these additional options appear asking for the method to use.

{{attachment:FEMConductivitiesAnisoPanel.JPG||width="250",height="300"}}

The available methods are:

- Effective Medium approach (EMA)

- Effective Medium approach with volume constraints  (EMA + VC)

- Simulated or the artificial anisotropy

Only the two first methods require the DTI. More information about these methods can be found on these references [ref1][ref2] and in our main paper [link]

In this tutorial, we use the method "EMA + VC", where the final tensors are constrained to fits the volume of the equivalent isotropic tensor volume.

==== Visulation of FEM mesh tensors ====
Once the FEM tensors are successfully computed, they are stored in the FEM head node. By right-clicking on the FEM head, new menu items are added that gives the possibilities to display the FEM tensors either as ellipsoids or as vectors in the direction of the main eigenvector.

{{attachment:menuDisplayTensors.jpg||width="250",height="300"}}

The tensors can be displayed either on the FEM mesh or overlaid on the MRI. The following figures show an example of the obtained tensors displayed on the white matter.

{{attachment:meshViewTensorsLines.JPG||width="350",height="300"}} {{attachment:meshViewTensorsTensorsTops.JPG||width="350",height="300"}}

On the left, the tensors as a line on the direction of the main eigenvector. On the right, the tensors displayed as ellipsoids. The orientation of the tensor is color-coded as follows: red for right-left, green for anterior-posterior, and blue for superior-inferior.

Note that the quality of the tensors depends on the DWI data and the number of acquisition direction.

Users can also display the tensors on specific tissues, for example on the white matter (left figure) or overlay on the MRI (right figure).

{{attachment:meshViewTensorsLinesWM2.JPG||width="350",height="300"}} {{attachment:tensorsOnMri.JPG||width="300",height="300"}}

==== Recommendation ====
In the case where the user wants to use generate isotropic tensors, then the DTI is not required. For that case, keep all the options to 'isotropic', the recommended display is the 'Ellipsoids', and the final shape will be a sphere (isotropic direction).   In the case where more than one FEM head model is in the database, the highlighted one in the green color will be used.

<<TAG(Advanced)>>

== Simulated conductivity tensor ==
In the case where the DWI is not available, or in the case where the users desire to evaluate the effect of the conductivity change on the head model, the artificial conductivity can be used.

Users can reach this option by following this tutorial and select the third method in this panel. {{attachment:artificialTensors.JPG||width="280",height="450"}}

Two approaches are integrated within Brainstorm. Either Wang's constraint or the volume's constraint (Wolters). The common feature between these methods is the ratio between the transversal and longitudinal conductivity ratio.

A common example is the skull anisotropy simulation, where the longitudinal conductivity can be higher than the transversal conductivity, the ratio can vary from 2 to 10 [ref]. In this tutorial, we keep all the tissue as isotropic, except the skull, we use a ratio of 0.1 and select the volume constraint. The following figures show the results of this example.

"eigenvalues parallel (longitudinal) and perpendicular (transverse) to the fiber directions" for 1:10 anisotropy (transverse:longitudinal)

{{attachment:skullAniso.JPG||width="300",height="250"}} {{attachment:skullAniso2.JPG||width="300",height="250"}}

== Troubleshooting ==
To be completed soon and linked to BrainSuite website
-Line 65:
+Line 149:
+===TODO===

Check the error in the simnibs mesh in X direction and overlay on mri check the error with the brain2mesh  Correct the ratio from integer to float  check the meaning of transversal/longitidunal in the code add an interactive way yo change the size of the tensor.. important   correct the name of the simulated method,   correct the EMC and remove the VC and change the coefficcient

Software

Users

Development